Michigan benched Bryce Underwood during the second half against Penn State on Saturday, turning to freshman Tommy Carr after the Wolverines’ offense managed zero points in the first 30 minutes. The move came a day after head coach Kyle Whittingham had publicly committed to Underwood as his starter, a reversal that unfolded in real time as Michigan searched for answers in a game that would decide which winless-in-conference team picked up its first Big Ten victory of the season.
The Main Development
Underwood struggled badly before getting pulled. He completed just 5 of 11 passes for 43 yards with no touchdowns and two interceptions in the first half, and Michigan totaled only 80 yards on 23 plays while being shut out. Carr, who had appeared only in garbage time this season, took over to try to jumpstart an offense that had stalled completely against Penn State’s defense.
Whittingham addressed the offensive issues at halftime in an interview with CBS Sports sideline reporter Jenny Dell, before Carr’s entrance became official. “Well, first of all, we got something going on offense. We’ve got absolutely nothing going.
We’re not running the ball well. The only team not running the ball as well as us is them. So, neither team can run the football.
But two turnovers. I don’t have an answer for you right now. We’re going to talk about it here at halftime.
We got to get something going,” Whittingham said, according to Sports Illustrated.
What It Means
The quarterback change marks a sharp turn from Whittingham’s stance just one day earlier. On Friday, the Michigan coach had told reporters, “Bryce is our guy, and we move forward,” according to Sporting News. Less than 24 hours later, with the Wolverines unable to move the ball and Underwood responsible for two turnovers, Whittingham made an in-game change instead.
Michigan’s ground game offered no relief either. Running back Jordan Marshall carried six times for 25 yards in the first half, and the team finished the opening two quarters with just 37 rushing yards total. Penn State’s defense was able to sell out against the run because Underwood and the passing attack gave it no reason to respect the air.
Context, Stats And Background
Underwood entered Saturday completing under 60% of his passes on the season, with 881 passing yards, five touchdowns and four interceptions. Through five games, Michigan was averaging 23 points and 315.8 yards per contest, numbers that place the Wolverines’ offense 68th nationally by ESPN’s SP+ metric. Among Michigan’s remaining opponents, only Michigan State, ranked 73rd, grades out worse by that measure.
Carr’s only previous game action came against UTEP on Sept. 19, when he completed two passes for 23 yards with one touchdown and added 18 rushing yards in a reserve role. The case for benching Underwood had been building before Saturday’s performance, given his interception total and inconsistent accuracy through the first five games.
What’s Next
Michigan entered Saturday at 3-2 overall and 0-2 in Big Ten play, while Penn State sat at 3-3 and 0-3 in conference games, meaning one team was guaranteed its first league win of the season. The sources do not detail Carr’s second-half performance or whether the change will carry into future games, and Michigan’s coaching staff had not issued a postgame explanation of the quarterback decision beyond Whittingham’s halftime comments. The Wolverines’ next test comes as they continue Big Ten play, a stretch previewed in Total Apex Sports’ look at the Michigan vs. Minnesota matchup.
Don't stop here
Every Score. Every Story. One Home.
Breaking sports, entertainment and news from across the Total Apex network, updated all day.
Get the Full Story →
