While the Super Bowl is still on the schedule, the NFL Draft season is in full swing. The journey from college football sensation to NFL quarterback is rarely a straight line. It is paved with intense scrutiny, rigorous evaluation, and often, harsh criticism from draft experts. Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia, who captivated the college football world with his electric play style and underdog victories, is now facing this reality head-on.
Todd McShay’s Brutal NFL Draft Analysis of Diego Pavia
As the 2026 NFL Draft approaches, renowned draft analyst Todd McShay has offered a candid and somewhat brutal assessment of Pavia’s professional prospects. While Pavia’s college career was defined by proving doubters wrong, McShay’s critique highlights the steep hill the Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia must climb to succeed at the next level.
Todd McShay Analysis: “I Don’t Think He Can Play Quarterback in the NFL”
Todd McShay didn’t mince words during a recent segment of “The Todd McShay Show.” When discussing the incoming class of quarterbacks, his evaluation of Pavia was stark. Despite acknowledging the fun and excitement Pavia brought to the college game, McShay expressed serious doubts about his translatability to the NFL.
“I don’t think Diego Pavia can play quarterback in the NFL,” McShay stated plainly.
McShay’s analysis focused heavily on the distinction between making plays in a chaotic college environment versus operating within the structure of an NFL offense. He praised Pavia’s instincts, noting his ability to change arm angles and create magic when plays break down—traits that made him a nightmare for SEC defenses. However, McShay pinpointed a critical weakness: the standard, structural throws required on Sundays.
“When you watch him just like the one-on-ones, seven-on-sevens having to drive the ball, NFL throws…it’s not the same as the other guys,” McShay explained.
This critique strikes at the heart of the “college star vs. pro prospect” debate. Pavia thrived on improvisation and grit at Vanderbilt, often willing his team to victory. But NFL evaluators like McShay look for repeatable mechanics, arm talent capable of fitting balls into tight windows, and the ability to win from the pocket—areas where Pavia seemingly falls short in comparison to his peers.
The Diego Pavia NFL Draft Profile
Diego Pavia’s rise to prominence is one of the best stories in recent college football history. After transferring to Vanderbilt, he revitalized a program that had long been the doormat of the SEC. In the 2025 season, he completed over 70 percent of his passes for 3,539 yards and 29 touchdowns, while adding another 862 yards and 10 scores on the ground.
His profile is that of a playmaker. He is the guy you want with the ball in his hands on 4th-and-5 with the game on the line. He has proven he can win against elite competition, most notably leading the Commodores to historic upsets.
However, his stock is complicated by his physical traits and play style. He lacks the prototypical size and elite arm strength that teams typically covet in early-round picks. His game relies heavily on mobility and off-script creativity, which can be harder to sustain against faster, more disciplined NFL defenses.
McShay’s comments reinforce the skepticism that many scouts likely share. While the production is undeniable, the tools required to be a consistent NFL starter may not be there.
Where Does Pavia Land?
Despite the harsh critique, it is unlikely that Pavia goes undrafted. The NFL is always in search of competitors, and teams often take flyers on quarterbacks with unique skill sets in the later rounds.
Most projections see Pavia as a Day 3 selection, potentially falling to the sixth or seventh round. Some analysts view him as a potential developmental prospect or a valuable backup who can bring energy to a quarterback room. His ability to run an offense effectively, even if unconventional, could appeal to teams looking for a specific type of depth.
Teams with creative offensive minds, such as the Miami Dolphins or Los Angeles Rams, might see value in Pavia’s ability to execute RPO-heavy concepts or serve as a mobile option in short-yardage situations. Alternatively, a team like the Indianapolis Colts or Denver Broncos might value his leadership and toughness enough to bring him into camp.
The Road Ahead
For Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia, Todd McShay’s comments are just the latest bulletin board material. Throughout his career, Pavia has thrived when expectations were low. He wasn’t supposed to succeed in the SEC, yet he did. He wasn’t supposed to be a draftable prospect, yet here he is.
The path to an NFL roster spot will be difficult. He will need to prove in training camp and preseason games that he can operate from the pocket and make “NFL throws” with consistency. While McShay may not see a future starter, Pavia has made a career out of proving experts wrong. Whether that trend continues on the professional stage remains one of the more intriguing storylines of the 2026 draft cycle.
Don't stop here
Every Score. Every Story. One Home.
Breaking sports, entertainment and news from across the Total Apex network, updated all day.
Get the Full Story →
