If you watch the NFL long enough, you convince yourself you’ve seen every possible way a special teams unit can implode. You’ve seen the “Double Doink,” the laces-in disasters, and the snap sailing over a punter’s head. But on Monday night, Younghoe Koo and the New York Giants offered up a new entry for the blooper reel—a field goal attempt that never actually became a kick.
In a play that perfectly encapsulated the Giants’ dismal 2-11 campaign, Koo lined up for what should have been a routine 47-yarder against the New England Patriots. The Giants were trailing, desperate for points, and looking to claw back some dignity before halftime. Instead, the turf at Gillette Stadium reached up and grabbed Koo’s foot, resulting in a “whiff” that looked more like a 25-handicap golfer chunking a pitching wedge than a professional football play.
Anatomy Of a “Phantom” Kick
Let’s break down exactly what happened, because the box score, which ruled the play a turnover on downs rather than a missed field goal, doesn’t do the comedy justice.
As Koo approached the ball, his plant foot dug into the ground. Then, in a moment of baffling physics, his kicking leg swung through and simply stopped. He didn’t shank it. He didn’t get blocked. He kicked the grass. The ball sat there, untouched, mocking the entire special teams unit.
Punter and holder Jamie Gillan was left holding a live grenade. With the defense closing in, Gillan scooped up the ball and scrambled, only to be swallowed up for a loss. On the sideline, rookie Quarterback Jaxson Dart stared in disbelief, wearing the expression of a man wondering what he did to deserve this specific circle of football hell.
The “Pull Up” Explanation
Post-game, Koo offered a rationale that actually makes sense, even if the optics were terrible. According to Koo, the ball slipped on the hold due to the cold conditions.
“I was approaching the ball and, cold weather, the ball kind of slipped out at the bottom, so it was moving,” Koo said to reporters. “I wasn’t able to kick through the ball. The ball was moving when I was driving to it, so I just pulled up on it.”
Essentially, Koo saw disaster coming and tried to abort the mission mid-motion. It was a split-second decision to save a bad hold, but the result was an image that will unfortunately live on in memes for the rest of the season.
A Microcosm Of New York’s Misery
While it’s easy to chuckle at the visual of a kicker fighting the ground (and losing), this play was just one sour note in a symphony of errors for New York. The Giants didn’t just lose 33-15; they were dismantled in the third phase of the game. Before the Koo incident, they gave up a 94-yard punt return touchdown. Later, a fumble on a kickoff return handed New England even more points.
For Koo, who is the third kicker to suit up for the Giants in this cursed 2025 season, it was a brutal night at the office. For the Giants faithful, it was just another Monday.
Don't stop here
Every Score. Every Story. One Home.
Breaking sports, entertainment and news from across the Total Apex network, updated all day.
Get the Full Story →
