Yankees Lose to the Diamondbacks 5-3 as Cam Schlittler Deals, though runs into Trouble in the 6th

Yankee pitcher Cam Schlittler

The Yankees beat the Diamondbacks 5-1 as the incomparable Cam Schlittler took the mound. Coming into this game, he had pitched 22 games allowing one run or less in his starts. Pundits once thought Toronto Blue Jays pitcher Dylan Cease was a contender for the American League Cy Young Award, but his last start was a disaster, so Schlitler has the inside track.

Aaron Judge says he is frustrated with his latest injury. He is not the only one, as fans of the team are frustrated as well. Do you think Aaron Judge will return for the postseason?

Yankees and Diamondbacks Game Summary September 18

Jul 17, 2026; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks second baseman Ketel Marte (4) turns a double play on St. Louis Cardinals catcher Jimmy Crooks (8) in the seventh inning at Chase Field. The Diamondbacks faced the Yankees September 19. Mandatory Credit: Matt Kartozian-Imagn Images
Jul 17, 2026; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks second baseman Ketel Marte (4) turns a double play on St. Louis Cardinals catcher Jimmy Crooks (8) in the seventh inning at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Matt Kartozian-Imagn Images

The Yankees were hoping to leverage their sparkling 9-2 victory last night to get the win tonight. They were also hoping to take advantage of the Cam Schlitler start. This is how the game played out.

The Yankees did not score five runs in the first inning of this game. In fact, they scored no runs in the first inning. Inning tonight.

In the fifth inning, Ben Rice hit a sacrifice fly, and Anthony Volpe scored. The Yankees led 1-0. However, in the bottom of the fifth inning, Jordan Lawlar tripled and two runs scored. Nolan Arenado scored, and Tim Tawa scored. Arizona led 2-1

In the sixth inning, the Yankees took the lead on two solo home runs. Heloit Ramos hit a home run, and then Austin Wells hit one. The Bombers led 3-2.

Arizona tied the game in the bottom of the sixth inning. Corbin Carroll hit a sacrifice fly, and Ketel Marte scored. The game was tied at three.

In the ninth inning, Pavin Smith hit a two-run pinch-hit home run, and Ildemaro Vargas scored. It was 5-3, which was the final score of the game.

Rematch of the 2001 World Series

This series was interesting because it was a rematch of the 2001 World Series played by these teams. That was twenty-five years ago, and the Diamondbacks beat the Yankees when everyone was rooting for them.

Everyone was rooting for the Yankees because that World Series happened right after the Sept. 11 attacks. That World Series was noteworthy both because of the unbeatable combination at the top of the Diamondbacks rotation: Randy Johnson and Curt Schilling. That World Series was also noteworthy because Derek Jeter earned the nickname “Mr. November” for hitting a walk-off home run off Arizona closer Byung-Hyun Kim right after midnight on November First.

Frequently Asked Questions 

The Yankees won this game 5-1 following another great start from Cam Schlitler. He was the player of the game. He pitched six innings and struck out six batters. He walked three batters and allowed three hits. He let in only one earned run, three runs overall. He continued to polish his Cy Young Award resume.

These two teams play the last game of their three-game series tomorrow at 4:10 pm. This is the last road game of the season for the Yankees. They are off Monday, as they fly across the country to New York to host the Rays in the biggest series of the year. Arizona on Monday and travel to Colorado Tuesday. The Diamondbacks have lost three games in a row coming into this one at the worst possible time. Their magic number four playoff elimination is four.

Conclusion

Schlitler is first in the American League in Earned Run Average. Third in Walks plus Innings pitched, with a microscopic .90. He came into this game fourth with 228 strikeouts, but he had more tonight. He was also 14-6 if you believe in win-loss records. Most impressive was his sparkling 21 games started allowing one run or fewer. He has given the Yankees a chance to win in every one of his starts. That is really all anyone can ask.