Yankees Beat Mets 2-0 in Subway Series Rubber Game as Cam Schlittler is Great

Cam Schlittler of the Yankees

The Yankees leveraged a start from Cy Young candidate Cam Schlittler to win the rubber game of the Subway Series against the New York Mets. Their score was 2-0. Schlittler has started 19 games this year and has allowed 1 or fewer earned runs. Dylan Cease of the Toronto Blue Jays is having a great year, but Schlittler is having a better one.

The Yankees had Aaron Judge in the lineup for the third consecutive game. He was playing right field today. It is becoming obvious that the team needs production from the bottom of the lineup. Austin Wells, Jose Caballero, and Ryan McMahon. Those three are automatic outs, so they need to get going. Do you think they will?

Yankees Against Mets Game Summary September 13

Former New York Mets manager Carlos Mendoza (64) speaks before a baseball game. The Mets wrap up a series today with the Yankees.
Apr 17, 2026; Chicago, Illinois, USA; New York Mets manager Carlos Mendoza (64) speaks before a baseball game against the Chicago Cubs at Wrigley Field. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-Imagn Images

The Yankees were hoping to leverage a start from Cam Schlittler, who has held opponents to one run or fewer in 19 starts. He may win the Cy Young Award in the American League. He was opposed by Christian Scott. He has pitched well this season, but was no match for Schlittler. Here is how the game played out.

In the first inning, Ben Rice led off the game with a solo home run. Then, in the third inning, Austin Wells hit a solo home run as well, breaking an 0-20 slump. The score was 2-0 Yankees.

The game stayed at this score for several innings as both starting pitchers, Cam Schlittler and Christian Scott, pitched well.

The Incomparable Cam Schlittler

Schlittler is basically a rookie. He pitched too much last season to be considered a rookie this year, though this is his first full season. What a season it is. The Yankees have found something in the 25-year-old starting pitcher. He is an incredible story as he topped out in the minor leagues at 92 miles per hour. He throws almost 100 miles per hour in the Major Leagues.

He has pitched an incredible 19 games where he has allowed one or fewer runs scored. He came into the game with a 13-6 record in 31 starts and 181.1 innings pitched. He has an earned run average of 1.98, and he has struck out 224 batters. His main competition for the American League Cy Young Award is Toronto’s Dylan Cease. He ranks right up there with other recent Yankee Cy Young winners.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Yankees won this game 2-0. The Yankees’ starting pitcher, Cam Schlittler, was the player of the game. He pitched seven shutout innings. He gave up only 2 hits and walked 2 batters, but he struck out 7 and lowered his earned run average to 1.94. Christian Scott pitched well for the Mets, but he was overshadowed by the brilliance of Schlittler.

This was the last game of the three-game Subway Series. It was also the last game of the season between these two clubs. The Yankees travel to Minnesota to take on the Twins at 7:40 tomorrow evening. The Mets go home to face the Baltimore Orioles. That series is interesting, between two teams who are just playing out the string, because it marks the return of Pete Alonso to Queens. The Polar Bear, as he is called, was a big star with the Mets before signing a free-agent contract with the Orioles in the offseason.

Conclusion

As the Tampa Rays just keep winning, they were leading the Houston Astros 8-0 after just three innings today. So, the Yankees have to win games as well. The Yankees, on paper, should be favored over the Rays. However, all year the Rays have consistently won games, so they could do so in the playoffs as well.