Alan Shearer says Fabian Hurzeler would be his top choice to replace Michael Carrick if Manchester United decide to make a managerial change, hours after the club’s 4-1 Champions League defeat to Como on Wednesday. The former Premier League winner’s comment is commentary, not a sign United are actively pursuing the Brighton manager, but it lands at a moment when questions about Carrick’s position are intensifying.
Shearer placed Hurzeler “at the top of his shortlist of three potential replacements should United decide to part ways with Michael Carrick,” according to Sky Sports. The outlet did not detail the other two names on that list.
Shearer’s Carrick Replacement Suggestion
Shearer’s remarks arrived the same day Manchester United were beaten 4-1 by Como, a result that has sharpened scrutiny of Carrick’s tenure. He also called the performance “not acceptable,” according to Sky Sports. The suggestion of Hurzeler as a Carrick replacement is Shearer’s personal opinion rather than any indication from United’s hierarchy, and no official statement from the club has addressed Carrick’s future.
Sky Sports also noted that former United player Ashley Young has warned the club that appointing Antonio Conte as manager would create difficulties, another name floated in outside commentary rather than confirmed United interest.
What It Means For United’s Managerial Uncertainty
Shearer’s comments reflect a broader pattern of outside voices weighing in on Carrick’s position rather than any concrete move from Old Trafford. Manchester United sit 13th in the Premier League table with one win in seven league matches and only two wins across all competitions this season, according to Sporting News. That record has created an opening for pundits to publicly debate replacement candidates even without any club confirmation that a change is being considered.
The pressure intensified further when captain Bruno Fernandes openly questioned Carrick’s tactical approach after the Como loss. “It’s a decision from the staff to not press man to man and sometimes leave space behind and try to get the ball, but sometimes when you give too much the ball to these teams they get confidence,” Fernandes said, per Sporting News. He added, “That’s on the manager and staff to see it, not me. Sometimes you have to be more brave under pressure, take the risk of pressing high and making them uncomfortable.”
Reaction To Fernandes’ Comments
Fernandes’ willingness to criticize his own manager publicly drew sharp reactions from former players turned broadcasters. Joe Cole, speaking on TNT Sports, called the comments sacrilege and said “you cannot come out and question the tactics.” Jamie Carragher, on CBS Sports, labeled Fernandes’ remarks “a disgrace,” pointing out that Fernandes won Player of the Year last season after benefiting from Carrick’s appointment as manager. Henry Winter also criticized Fernandes for questioning Carrick following the Como defeat, according to Sky Sports.
The split reaction shows the uncertainty extends beyond the dugout. A captain breaking ranks to question tactics, combined with a Ballon d’Or-caliber pundit publicly naming a replacement candidate, signals how exposed Carrick’s position looks even without any formal move from United’s board.
Team Context Against Como
Carrick’s setup against Como was also shaped by a depleted squad. United were missing nine first-team players for the match, eight through injury and one through suspension, according to USA Today. Leny Yoro was suspended after a red card in the previous defeat to Atletico Madrid, while center back Matthijs de Ligt made his return from a back injury and subsequent surgery.
Those absences do not appear in Fernandes’ tactical criticism or Shearer’s managerial commentary, but they form part of the backdrop against which Carrick is being judged this season.
What’s Next
No official word has come from Manchester United on Carrick’s job security, and there is no confirmation the club has considered Hurzeler, Conte or any other name. Carrick’s side will look to respond to the Como defeat and a league campaign that has produced just one win in seven matches as the schedule continues.
Don't stop here
Every Score. Every Story. One Home.
Breaking sports, entertainment and news from across the Total Apex network, updated all day.
Get the Full Story →
