The New York Islanders and Toronto Maple Leafs meet for the second time this season on Saturday, Oct. 17, with the Islanders vs Maple Leafs preview headlined by two clubs trying to find consistency early in the 2026-27 campaign. Toronto beat New York 2-1 in their first meeting, and the Maple Leafs will try to complete the season-series sweep at home. The Islanders enter at 3-3-1 while the Maple Leafs sit at 3-3-2, but New York holds a notable edge in goal differential that could make this matchup closer than the standings suggest.
Islanders Vs Maple Leafs Game Information
- Date: Saturday, Oct. 17
- Time: 7 p.m. ET
- Venue: Scotiabank Arena, Toronto, Ontario
- TV/Streaming: ESPN+, MSGSN
- Series: Toronto leads the season series 1-0
By The Numbers
- Record: Islanders 3-3-1, Maple Leafs 3-3-2
- Goals for: Islanders 20, Maple Leafs 28
- Goals against: Islanders 16, Maple Leafs 27
- Goal differential: Islanders +4, Maple Leafs +1
- Save percentage: Islanders .927, Maple Leafs .889
- Average goals against: Islanders 2.29, Maple Leafs 3.38
- Shooting percentage: Islanders 11.2%, Maple Leafs 12.6%
- Power-play goals: Islanders 4, Maple Leafs 8
- Faceoff percentage: Islanders 53.6%, Maple Leafs 52.4%
Islanders Outlook
New York carries the best goal differential of the two teams at plus-4, built on a defense that has allowed just 16 goals through seven games for a 2.29 average against. The Islanders’ .927 team save percentage ranks well ahead of Toronto’s .889 mark, a sign that goaltending has kept New York competitive even with a modest 20 goals scored.
The Islanders are 0-2-1 on the road this season, a split that will be tested at Scotiabank Arena. Bo Horvat leads the club with four goals and seven points, while rookie defenseman Matthew Schaefer paces the team with six assists. Ilya Sorokin is the projected starting goalie for New York. Center Mathew Barzal remains out with a knee injury, and defenseman Alexander Romanov is out after undergoing surgery on his right knee for an ACL injury.
Maple Leafs Outlook
Toronto has scored 28 goals this season, the most of the two clubs, with Auston Matthews leading the NHL-caliber attack with six goals, seven assists and 13 points. The Maple Leafs are 2-2-1 at home, and their power play has converted eight times, double New York’s total.
Toronto’s most recent outing ended in a 5-4 overtime loss to the Buffalo Sabres on Oct. 15, a game in which Buffalo’s Kirill Marchenko scored a hat trick, according to the Associated Press. Sergei Bobrovsky is the projected starting goalie. The Maple Leafs are dealing with a lengthy injury list that includes center John Tavares, listed day to day with a lower-body injury, along with Dakota Joshua (abdomen), Max Domi (back), Chris Tanev (upper body), Miles Wood, Cade Webber (elbow), Elvis Merzlikins (shoulder) and William Villeneuve (knee), all out. Toronto added forward Aatu Räty in a trade with the Vancouver Canucks this week, sending Jacob Quillan and Brandon Buhr to Vancouver in return, according to ESPN.
Key Matchup
Toronto’s offense, which has produced 28 goals on a 12.6% shooting clip, will face an Islanders defense that has surrendered the second-fewest goals in this pairing at 16. New York’s penalty minutes total of 87 compared to Toronto’s 67 suggests the Islanders could spend more time killing penalties, which would test a Maple Leafs power play already operating at eight goals on the man advantage. How Sorokin handles a Toronto lineup still generating offense without Tavares, who has missed time with a lower-body injury, will go a long way toward determining whether New York’s road struggles continue or its stingy defense travels well.
What To Watch
Toronto enters shorthanded up front with Tavares day to day and five other forwards or defensemen out, which could put more scoring pressure on Matthews and the newly acquired Räty. The Islanders, meanwhile, will try to build on their plus-4 goal differential despite a winless road record away from UBS Arena this season. Both teams sit in the middle of tightly packed divisions, Toronto in the Atlantic and New York in the Metropolitan, making every early-season point valuable as the schedule thickens. The Islanders’ recent trip included a 2-1 shootout loss at Ottawa on Oct. 15, as detailed in Islanders Lose to Senators 2-1 as Semyon Varlamov Starts Again, and New York will look to carry any momentum from that stretch into Scotiabank Arena.
Don't stop here
Every Score. Every Story. One Home.
Breaking sports, entertainment and news from across the Total Apex network, updated all day.
Get the Full Story →
