Yankees Beat Guardians 3-2 Behind Gerrit Cole Up-And-Down Start

May 10, 2024; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA; New York Yankees pitcher Garret Cole (45) looks on against the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field.

The Yankees got a strong start in this game from Gerrit Cole in his third game back since his injury. The Yankees won this game 3-2. It is funny, but with the injury to Aaron Judge, this is how the team is going to have to play games now. That is leverage their good starting pitching to keep the scoring low.

Gerrit Cole has been a little inconsistent for the Yankees so far this season. He was not scored upon in his first two starts. However, he gave up three home runs in his last start. He lost against the Cleveland Guardians. In his three previous starts this season, he had struck out two, ten, and two batters. Which Cole did you think would show up in this game?

Yankees and Guardians Game Summary June 9

Cleveland Guardians starting pitcher Parker Messick (77) delivers a pitch.
Apr 16, 2026; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Cleveland Guardians starting pitcher Parker Messick (77) delivers a pitch in the third inning against the Baltimore Orioles at Progressive Field. Mandatory Credit: David Richard-Imagn Images

This game started well for the Yankees. Spencer Jones hit a two-run home run in the second inning. Jazz Chisholm Jr. had walked just before. The Bronx Bombers led 2-0. The home run Jones hit. His first ever as a professional was a guady 443 feet.

In the third inning, that Yankee killer, Jose Ramirez, singled and then stole second base. He scored on a Chase DeLaughter single. Gerrit Cole then walked Kyle Mazardo and hit Rhys Hoskins to load the bases. Angel Martinez then hit an infield single, and Paul Goldschmidt made a great play, but Martinez beat a sliding Cole to first base. The second run scored.

In the eighth inning, Jazz Chisholm Jr. hit a solo home run, giving the Yankees a 3-2 lead. Now it was just a question of whether the bullpen could hold the lead.

The Prodigious Power

Spencer Jones hit his first career home run in this game for the Yankees. He is a hulking prospect for the team, who was called up to replace the roster spot of injured Aaron Judge. There was some doubt that Jones could succeed in the Major Leagues. He did strike out a lot in the minors. However, he also had a reputation for being very powerful and having a lot of speed. The team hoped he could fill the void, at least partially, left by the injured slugger.

Jones is as tall as Judge at 6 feet 7. Like Judge, he is also a good baserunner. His athleticism reminds some of Judge. He just needs to live up to his potential. The new slugger did have seven singles and a double in his previous games in Major League Baseball, so he has not looked completely overmatched. He has also played excellent defense in right field for the Bronx Bombers. He certainly fits the Bomber bill. They would have a great basketball team.

Cole Inconsistency

There is no question that once Max Fried returns from his injury, the Yankees will have one of the best starting pitching rotations in the Majors. Gerrit Cole has looked dominant at times in his return from injury. He was not scored upon in his first two games back from injury. However, he lost his game to these Cleveland Guardians.

Cole also struggled in this game, giving up two runs. By that point, he was wilting in the heat and humidity of Cleveland. He was not hit very hard, though he was a little wild. Cole threw 28 pitches in that inning. After that hard work, Cole was not long for this game. That was unfortunate, given that the Pinstripers used all but one relief pitcher last night. At no point in this game did Cole look comfortable; he was removed after just four innings pitched, having given up two runs.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Yankees looked like they were going to lose this game, but they did not, winning 3-2. The player of this game was Spencer Jones, who hit his first career home run for the Bombers. Then he singled and ‘popped out’ to the wall in Left. These two teams conclude their three-game series tomorrow at 1:10 PM.

Conclusion

This was yet another close and winnable game for the Yankees. The team, who are playing the longest games in the Majors, managed to overcome a shaky third inning from starting pitcher Gerrit Cole, and several blown opportunities to win this game 3-2. Now they go for a series sweep tomorrow afternoon.