49ers Sign K Eddy Piñeiro
The San Francisco 49ers didn’t mess around. Less than 48 hours after watching Jake Moody single-handedly try to torpedo their season opener against Seattle, they showed him the door and brought in veteran Eddy Piñeiro to clean up the mess.
You could feel the collective exhale from every 49ers fan who’s been holding their breath for two-plus seasons every time Moody lined up for anything beyond an extra point. The third-round pick who was supposed to be the answer to their kicking woes instead became the question nobody wanted to ask: How did we get this so wrong?
The Final Straw That Broke San Francisco’s Patience
Sunday’s performance against the Seahawks was the kind of nightmare that haunts coaches in their sleep. Moody shanked a 27-yarder that should have been automatic, then watched helplessly as his 36-yard attempt got swatted down like he was kicking in a middle school scrimmage. Going 1-for-3 in a game the Niners barely escaped with their lives was the writing on the wall in 72-point font.
This wasn’t some fluke performance either. Moody’s been a walking anxiety attack for Faithful fans since day one. Remember those clutch moments when you need your kicker to come through? Moody was 16-of-29 from beyond 40 yards in his career. That’s not just inconsistent, that’s franchise-threatening in January when championships are won and lost by three points.
The Michigan product came to Santa Clara with all the hype about his powerful leg, but power means nothing when you can’t find the uprights. Every time the 49ers got into field goal range, it felt like a coin flip whether they’d come away with points or punt the ball back to the other team.
Piñeiro Brings Proven Track Record and Steady Nerves
Enter Eddy Piñeiro, who’s been waiting for this exact opportunity. The 29-year-old veteran brings something Moody never could: reliability when it matters most. During his three seasons in Carolina, Piñeiro converted 88.9% of his field goals and 92% of his extra points. Those aren’t just numbers, they’re the foundation of trust between a kicker and his team.
Piñeiro’s journey to this moment reads like a masterclass in perseverance. Undrafted out of Florida, he bounced around practice squads and injury reports before finding his groove with the Bears in 2019. After missing the entire 2020 season with an injury, he worked his way back through stops with the Jets and finally carved out a home in Carolina.
The guy even held the NFL’s all-time field goal percentage record at one point last season. That’s the kind of accuracy and consistency the 49ers desperately needed but couldn’t get from their former third-round investment.
Kyle Shanahan’s Difficult but Necessary Decision
You have to respect Kyle Shanahan for pulling the trigger when he did. Lesser coaches might have stuck with Moody longer, hoping the investment would eventually pay off. But Shanahan knows championship windows don’t stay open forever, and every missed kick in a tight NFC is potentially the difference between January football and January golf.
The timing couldn’t be more critical either. The 49ers are built to win now, with an aging roster that includes key players on the wrong side of 30. They can’t afford to leave points on the field because their kicker gets the yips in pressure situations.
What This Means for San Francisco’s Championship Hopes
This move sends a clear message to the locker room: nobody’s job is safe if they’re not performing. It also removes one of the biggest question marks hanging over this team. How many games over the past two seasons could have gone differently with reliable kicking?
The 49ers’ championship aspirations were always going to come down to margins. In a loaded NFC with teams like Detroit, Philadelphia and Dallas all making moves, San Francisco couldn’t afford to keep rolling the dice every time they crossed midfield.
Piñeiro gives them something they haven’t had in years: a kicker they can actually trust in crunch time. No more holding your breath on 35-yarders. No more wondering if a game-winning attempt is going to sail wide right. Just steady, professional kicking from a guy who’s been there and done that.
The Draft Pick That Became a Cautionary Tale
The Moody experiment will go down as one of those draft decisions that looks worse with every passing day. Using a third-round pick on a kicker is already a questionable move, but when that kicker can’t deliver in the clutch, it becomes a franchise-altering mistake.
Roberto Aguayo’s name probably came up in more than one conversation this week. The Buccaneers’ second-round kicker washout serves as the cautionary tale for reaching too high on specialists. Moody joins that unfortunate club of highly drafted kickers who couldn’t handle the NFL pressure.
The 49ers’ front office deserves credit for cutting their losses before it got worse. Some teams would have stuck with the sunk cost, hoping their investment would eventually mature. San Francisco chose winning over pride, and that’s exactly the kind of decision that separates contenders from pretenders.
This kicking change might seem like a small move, but in the razor-thin margins of NFL playoff races, it could be the difference between hoisting the Lombardi Trophy and watching it on television. Piñeiro’s got the chance to be a hero in San Francisco, and the 49ers finally have a kicker they can count on when everything’s on the line.
