Does Antony Have a Future at Manchester United?

When Manchester United spent £82 million to sign Antony from Ajax in 2022, there were a lot of expectations for the winger. The Brazilian was one of the best wingers in the world under Erik ten Hag in Amsterdam, and fans hoped he’d replicate that magic at Old Trafford. But fast forward to 2025, it isn’t quite the case. The 25-year-old is set to leave the club, and the manager who bought him left long ago.

After two seasons marked by inconsistency, limited goal contributions, and off-field distractions, Antony was loaned to Real Betis in January. With United’s new manager Rúben Amorim overseeing a dramatic squad overhaul, the question arises: Is there a future for the Brazilian star at Manchester United?

A Story of Unfulfilled Promise

Antony’s arrival at United was met with excitement. He was quick, tricky, and had the kind of flair fans crave. His debut goal against Arsenal was electric, but it ended up being one of the few standout moments in a largely underwhelming Red Devils career.

Over 18 months, the Brazilian managed just eight goals and three assists in 55 Premier League appearances, which fall well below expectations for a player in his position. His one-dimensional play, which was always cutting inside on his left, became increasingly predictable, and he struggled to assert himself physically in a league that demands intensity and adaptability.

Off the field, things didn’t get much easier. He reportedly grappled with mental health challenges, a situation made worse by the pressure of his hefty transfer fee and a string of personal legal troubles. Although no formal charges were filed, the controversy overshadowed his time in Manchester and added to the tension within the squad.

A Career Reboot

In January 2025, Manchester United decided to loan Antony to La Liga side Real Betis. For many, this felt like a make-or-break moment. But to his credit, Antony grabbed the opportunity with both hands.

He’s looked revitalized in Spain. In just 25 games, he tallied nine goals and five assists across all competitions, playing a key role in Betis’ impressive run to the UEFA Conference League final, where they unfortunately lost 4-1 to Chelsea. The less physical and slower pace of La Liga seems to complement his game, and the creative freedom he’s been given has allowed him to play with more confidence, something he struggled to do in Manchester.

Antony seems settled now. Spanish outlets like Cadena SER and Marca report that he’s told close friends he feels settled in Seville and is very open to making the move permanent. His teammates at Betis have also spoken highly of his professionalism and contribution, a refreshing contrast to how he was perceived during his time in England.

Rúben Amorim’s United Vision

With Erik ten Hag now gone, Manchester United have turned to Rúben Amorim, the former Sporting CP manager known for his tactical flexibility and youth development in a 3-4-3 formation. Amorim is planning a major clear-out this summer, and according to The Sun and MEN Sport, Antony is among 10 players the club is willing to offload.

The reason is simple: Amorim’s system requires wingers who can press, create chances, and score regularly. They are more attacking midfielders than wingers. While Antony may fit that mold on paper, his Premier League output so far doesn’t match what’s needed. Additionally, his high salary makes him a financial liability for a player who’s now the second choice.

United are reportedly open to selling Antony for around £35–£40 million, a significant loss on their original investment. However, Antony’s stock has fallen in England, and unless he continues to thrive at Betis or elsewhere, it’s hard to see a top Premier League club taking a gamble on him.

What’s Next for Antony?

The ball is now in Real Betis’ court. The Spanish side would love to keep him, but finances are tight. A permanent deal may be out of reach, although another loan is still on the table. Betis manager Manuel Pellegrini has publicly praised Antony’s impact and wants him as a core part of their squad next season. For Antony, remaining in Spain might be the most intelligent decision.

He’s regained his self-belief, rediscovered his rhythm, and reshaped how he’s perceived both on and off the pitch. A return to Manchester, where the pressure is suffocating and his role uncertain, might only set him back. At 25, time is still on his side. His technical ability has always been there; the consistency, composure, and right tactical fit have been missing. Currently, Manchester United no longer appears to be the right environment for him to grow.

Final Thoughts

Unless there’s a complete U-turn by Amorim or a dramatic improvement in form and attitude, Antony’s days at Manchester United are likely over. The club is looking to move forward with a leaner, more aggressive squad, and he doesn’t seem to fit the plan. His resurgence at Betis proves he still has a lot to offer. Perhaps it was never about Antony not being good enough, but rather that United was not the right place for him to showcase it, which has sadly been the case for many players.