Shedeur Sanders

When Silent Treatment Goes Wrong: Shedeur Sanders’ Press Conference Pantomime Backfires

Justin Rimpi

The Cleveland Browns quarterback situation just got a whole lot weirder, and that is saying something for a franchise that’s seen more drama than a daytime soap opera. While the football world was digesting the news that rookie Dillon Gabriel would replace Joe Flacco as the starter, third-string quarterback Shedeur Sanders decided to steal the spotlight in the most bizarre way possible. What transpired?

Sanders Loses His Voice At the Worst Possible Time

When asked about his role as QB3 following Gabriel’s promotion, Sanders didn’t utter a single word. Instead, he mouthed his responses with that signature smile, shrugged his shoulders, and basically turned what should have been a routine media session into an uncomfortable theater experience. The whole thing lasted several minutes, with reporters desperately trying to get actual words out of him.

“What can you say?” one reporter finally asked, probably wondering if Sanders had temporarily lost his ability to speak. Spoiler alert: he hadn’t. The performance was reportedly Sanders’ response to ESPN analyst Rex Ryan absolutely roasting him earlier in the week. Ryan didn’t hold back, saying Sanders talks and “runs his mouth” while crossing his arms like he deserves to be a starting quarterback. “Get your ass in the front row and study,” Ryan said. “You should be embarrassed that you’re not the quarterback now.”

Ouch. That is the kind of criticism that would make any young player want to retreat into their shell – or in Sanders’ case, become a human charades champion.

Why This Silent Protest Missed the Mark

Look, we get it. Getting criticized on national television stings, especially when you’re a rookie trying to prove yourself in the world’s toughest football league. Sanders probably thought he was being clever, maybe even sending a message about media criticism. But here’s the thing about silent protests in the NFL – they usually create more noise than staying quiet would have.

The son of Colorado coach and Pro Football Hall of Famer Deion Sanders has been under an intense spotlight since being drafted in the fifth round. Unlike most third-string quarterbacks who blend into the background, Sanders carries the weight of his famous last name and the expectations that come with it. Every move he makes gets scrutinized, every comment gets analyzed.

But that is exactly why this mime routine was such a miscalculation. Instead of deflecting attention away from Ryan’s criticism, Sanders created an entirely new storyline about his maturity and professionalism. The very thing he was probably trying to avoid, more negative headlines, became inevitable.

The Browns’ QB Circus Continues

Cleveland’s quarterback situation has been anything but smooth this season. Flacco, the 40-year-old veteran who was supposed to provide stability, couldn’t get the offense moving consistently. Now, Gabriel, taken in the third round out of Oregon, gets his shot while Sanders remains on the sideline despite his draft pedigree and famous bloodline.

Sanders has been vocal about his readiness to play, recently telling reporters he could perform better than some current NFL starters. While confidence is crucial for any quarterback, there’s a fine line between belief and brashness – and Sanders keeps dancing on that line.

The frustrating part for the rookie has to be watching Gabriel leapfrog him in the depth chart. Both were rookies competing for playing time, but Gabriel has consistently been ahead since training camp. An oblique injury sidelined Sanders during the preseason, and he struggled in his final exhibition appearance while Gabriel excelled.

Learning Curve In the Spotlight

Every rookie faces growing pains, but most don’t have to navigate them while cameras follow their every move. Sanders turned down opportunities with playoff contenders like Philadelphia and Baltimore to land in Cleveland, presumably believing it offered a clearer path to playing time. That path just got murkier.

The silent treatment will blow over eventually – it’s not like Sanders committed some major transgression. But in a league where perception often becomes reality, these kinds of incidents stick around longer than they should. Veterans and coaches notice when young players handle adversity poorly, and it affects trust and respect in the locker room.

What Sanders needs now is fewer headlines and more reps. Instead of creating drama during press conferences, he should be boring reporters with clichéd responses while putting in extra work behind the scenes. That is how backup quarterbacks eventually become starters.

The Browns already have enough dysfunction without their third-string quarterback adding to the circus. At 1-3, Cleveland needs players focused on football, not media strategies. Sanders has undeniable talent – the same talent that made him one of college football’s top prospects. But talent alone won’t get him on the field if decision-makers question his judgment and maturity.

Sometimes the best response to criticism is no response at all. Other times, it’s simply doing your job better. Sanders chose a third option that helped nobody, least of all himself.

Justin has been a sportswriter for nearly a decade. He has previously written for 247 Sports an Sports Illustrated.

More Great Content