Alonso and Mayo 2026 Slow Starts Explained: How Baltimore’s Offense Is Adjusting?

The Baltimore Orioles entered the season with massive expectations and a fanbase eager to see a revamped lineup crush opposing pitching. Things have not gone exactly to plan. Two crucial pieces of the puzzle are struggling to find their rhythm at the plate, raising concerns just a few weeks into the schedule.

Pete Alonso arrived with a blockbuster offseason contract, promising a reliable source of middle-of-the-order power. Coby Mayo generated immense hype during spring training, looking like a homegrown talent ready to secure a permanent starting job. Instead, both players have stumbled out of the gate.

Baseball is notoriously difficult to predict in small samples. A bad week at the plate can look like a disaster in early April. We are going to look at the factors causing these early slumps, how the coaching staff is responding, and what it means for the team moving forward.

The Heavy Burden of a Massive New Contract

When a veteran slugger signs a five-year deal worth $155 million, fans expect immediate fireworks. Alonso built his reputation as a premier power hitter and a five-time All-Star. The Orioles front office brought him in to accelerate their return to consistent offensive dominance.

Through April 7th, the results have been underwhelming. Alonso is sporting a sluggish slash line with just one home run to his name. He looks a bit out of sync at the plate, occasionally chasing pitches out of the strike zone and missing fastballs he usually drives into the bleachers.

Alonso has publicly acknowledged his frustration with the slow start. He also emphasized that baseball is a long season. He views this initial slump as a temporary setback in a grueling 162-game race. The veteran is currently focusing on getting his timing right and executing basic fundamentals to get back on track.

I’m not worried about Pete’s slow start, although he had another 0-for-4 day in the game vs Chicago earlier in Tuesday’s win, but the Polar Bear does need to step it up soon because this lineup can’t just rely on Gunnar Henderson and Adley Rutschman’s bat forever, although those guys are capable of carrying the lineup.

Flashing Leather but Searching for Hits

The situation at third base presents a completely different challenge. Mayo earned his spot on the roster by putting together a spectacular spring training campaign. His defensive skills have been a major bright spot for the team. He routinely makes difficult plays look routine, saving runs and helping out the pitching staff.

His bat has not matched his glove. Updated stats through April 7th show Mayo struggling with a very low batting average and an uncomfortably high strikeout rate. The young infielder is facing major league pitching daily, and the adjustment period is proving difficult.

Baseball analysts have pointed out a few silver linings in Mayo’s offensive profile. He is generating hard contact when he does put the bat on the ball, but he has suffered from bad luck on balls in play. Experts recommend that Mayo adopt a more aggressive approach early in counts. Swinging at early strikes could help him reduce his strikeout rate and finally convert that hard contact into base hits.

I would recommend Mayo be benched regularly for a little bit when Jackson Holiday comes back for Blaze Alexander, unless he shows massive improvements over the next couple of games.

How the Slumps Alter Lineup Strategy

These combined struggles have a direct impact on how the Orioles operate daily. With Alonso missing his expected power output, the rest of the lineup faces increased pressure to produce runs. Opposing pitchers are attacking the Baltimore hitters differently, knowing the big bat in the middle is currently vulnerable.

Managerial decisions regarding playing time are also becoming complicated. Mayo provides so much value on defense that the team wants to keep him on the field. The coaching staff is working hard behind the scenes to help him fix his swing mechanics without shattering his confidence.

New additions to the Baltimore coaching staff are stressing clean play and strong fundamentals. They believe the roster will stabilize once key players return from early-season injuries.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Pete Alonso’s numbers looking like so far?

Through April 7th, Alonso has struggled to hit for average and has only managed to hit one home run. His overall slash line is sitting well below his career averages.

Why does Coby Mayo keep starting games?

The Orioles highly value Mayo’s defensive abilities at third base. His glove is currently keeping him in the starting lineup while the coaching staff waits for his bat to catch up.

Will the Orioles make roster moves if the slumps continue?

Small sample sizes usually correct themselves over a full season. If these issues drag on for months, the front office might explore platoon options or minor league call-ups to fix the offensive production.

Remaining Patient in a Long Season

The narrative surrounding Pete Alonso and Coby Mayo will continue to evolve as the Orioles navigate the schedule. Baseball rewards patience. Track records indicate that Alonso will eventually find his power stroke, and Mayo has the raw talent to adjust to major league pitching.

Fans should keep a close eye on the upcoming homestand. Watch for subtle changes in Alonso’s batting stance and see if Mayo starts attacking the first pitch of his at-bats. Health and fundamental execution will ultimately decide if Baltimore can reach its championship ceiling this year.

For More Great Content

Follow my X account @30BEllis for more of my articles from here, as well as my Instagram @_bellis32, and another place where you can access my articles. Also, please visit my author page at the bottom of the page here for more great content on the Philadelphia Eagles and much more across all sports.