Jack Suwinski Saga: Did the Pirates Make a $1.25 Million Mistake?
Just when you thought the Pittsburgh Pirates might be ready to play with the big boys this offseason, they pull a move straight out of the bargain bin. The non-tender deadline was looming, a time for teams to make tough, adult decisions about their roster. Instead of a bold statement, the Pirates opted for… well, the most Pirates-thing imaginable. They avoided arbitration with outfielder Jack Suwinski, handing him a guaranteed $1.25 million contract for the 2026 season.
Let that sink in. This wasn’t a move to lock down a rising star, but to lock in a depth piece for the minor leagues. Fans had every right to expect this to be an easy “thanks, but no thanks.” Instead, General Manager Ben Cherington decided to spend a cool million-plus on a lottery ticket that looks like it’s already been scratched off.
The Curious Case of Jack Suwinski
Remember 2023? Back then, Suwinski was a legitimate power threat, leading the team with 26 home runs and a respectable .793 OPS. He looked like a core piece, a guy you could build around. We were all dreaming of moonshots and clutch hits. However, it’s the Pittsburgh Pirates, and those dreams came to a crashing halt. In 2024, his production nosedived to a paltry .182 average. It was bad, but the worst part is that he regressed further.
This past season was a full-blown disaster. In just 59 games, Jack Suwinski managed a batting line of .147/.281/.253 with a mere three home runs. He wasn’t just struggling; he was an automatic out. His bat had more holes in it than a block of Swiss cheese, and pitchers exploited it with glee. High fastballs?
Forget about it. Left-handed pitchers? Might as well have sent him to the plate with a pool noodle. So, when the arbitration deadline approached, Suwinski was the poster child for a non-tender. It was the most apparent, clear-cut decision on the Pirates’ plate. And yet, here we are.
What Does This Deal Really Mean for the Pirates?
Let’s be brutally honest. This $1.25 million deal isn’t a vote of confidence. It’s a cheap gamble. The Pirates saw a player projected to earn more, negotiated him down, and patted themselves on the back for their fiscal prudence. But saving a few hundred thousand dollars on a player who can’t hit his weight isn’t a win; it’s a symptom of a larger problem.
This contract doesn’t guarantee Jack Suwinski a spot on the Opening Day roster. It doesn’t even guarantee he’ll be on the 40-man roster when the snow melts. What it does is buy him one last, desperate chance to prove he’s not thoroughly washed. He’s out of minor league options, so come spring training, it’s do-or-die. If he suddenly rediscovers his 2023 form, the Pirates look like geniuses, which is a rarity with the stench of cheapness.
Here’s the kicker: any team that claims him would be on the hook for his salary. Good luck with that. The more likely scenario is that he passes through waivers, and the Pirates are stuck paying $1.25 million for a guy to ride the buses in Triple-A Indianapolis. Now, could he be trade bait or attached to a future blockbuster Paul Skenes trade with the Yankees?
Final Thoughts
This move screams that the front office is hedging its bets and being cheap instead of actively pursuing upgrades. With a reported $30-40 million to spend, retaining a struggling outfielder for pocket change feels less like a strategy and more like a security blanket. For a team and a fanbase starved for meaningful progress, it’s a deflating start to a critical offseason.
