Rocchio and Naylor’s Clutch Home Runs Powers Guardians’ Stunning Comeback, Force Decisive Game 3 Against Tigers

The Cleveland Guardians, on the brink of elimination in the eighth inning, erupted for five runs led by a Brayan Rocchio homer,  storming past the Detroit Tigers 6-1 on Wednesday. The win evens the American League Wild Card Series at one game apiece.

The winner-take-all Game 3 is set for Thursday, with a trip to the AL Division Series against the Seattle Mariners hanging in the balance. For the Tigers, it was a night of crushing missed opportunities, leaving an astonishing 15 runners on base and going a dismal 1-for-15 with runners in scoring position. The inability to deliver a timely hit will surely haunt them as they face a do-or-die scenario.

Rocchio Homer Breaks 1-1 Tie  

The game was a nail-biting, 1-1 deadlock heading into the bottom of the eighth, with every pitch feeling heavier than the last. That’s when Rocchio, the Guardians’ second baseman, turned on a blistering 99.9 mph fastball from Tigers reliever Troy Melton, launching a solo home run that sent the home crowd into a frenzy. The blast broke the tension and opened the floodgates for Cleveland. An RBI double from Daniel Schneemann followed, extending the lead and setting the stage for the knockout blow. With two outs, catcher Bo Naylor stepped to the plate and delivered the dagger. He golfed a sweeper from lefty Brant Hurter over the right-field wall for a three-run homer, blowing the game wide open at 6-1. 

The dugout erupted, and the stadium rocked with the realization that their team had fought its way back from the edge. It was a stunning display of clutch hitting from a team that had been mostly silent for seven innings, validating manager Stephen Vogt’s faith in his young players. 

The Tigers, in contrast, couldn’t buy a run. They loaded the bases with two outs in the top of the ninth, a final glimmer of hope. But Guardians closer Cade Smith induced a sharp lineout from Dillon Dingler to end the threat and the game, leaving Detroit to wonder what could have been. A pivotal overturned call in the fourth inning, where a great throw from rookie Chase DeLauter nabbed a runner at third, kept a go-ahead run off the board for the Tigers and loomed large as the game wore on.

You can run and you can hide, but Postseason Rocchio is inevitable.#GuardsBall pic.twitter.com/fSfEf6iQTt

— Cleveland Guardians (@CleGuardians) October 1, 2025

What’s Next: A Winner-Take-All Showdown

Now, it all comes down to one game. The Guardians have seized the momentum behind the power of Rocchio, and Naylor, while the Tigers must quickly regroup from a frustrating loss defined by squandered chances.

• Deciding Game: The Tigers will send right-hander Jack Flaherty (8-15, 4.64 ERA) to the mound for his eighth career postseason start. The Guardians will counter with righty Slade Cecconi (7-7, 4.30 ERA), who will be making his playoff debut.
• For the winner: The winner will travel to Seattle for Game 1 of the ALDS on Saturday, Oct. 4.