Shohei Ohtani Sees Historic Night Wasted In Loss To Philadelphia Phillies

Picture this: You’re watching Michael Jordan drop 50 points in Game 6 of the Finals, except his teammates decide to play defense with their eyes closed in the fourth quarter. That’s basically what happened Tuesday night at Dodger Stadium when Shohei Ohtani delivered a performance for the ages, only to watch his bullpen teammates flush it down the drain faster than you can say “blooper reel.” How did everything get off track?

Ohtani Delivers Pure Baseball Poetry

Shohei Ohtani creates a new 50-50 club!

He's the first player in MLB history with 50 homers and 50 strikeouts in the same season 😮 pic.twitter.com/5jIiF3bv7i

— MLB (@MLB) September 17, 2025

For five innings, Ohtani was untouchable. Not just good—untouchable. The two-way superstar carved up the Phillies like a master chef working prime rib, throwing five hitless frames while striking out five batters and walking just one. His fastball was humming at 99.2 mph on average, touching 101.7 mph when he needed to remind hitters who was boss. His slider? A crisp 89 mph that had Phillies batters looking like they were swinging at ghosts.

But here’s the kicker—Ohtani wasn’t done showing off. In the eighth inning, he stepped into the batter’s box and absolutely obliterated a cutter, sending it 430 feet over the right-field wall at 113.4 mph exit velocity for his 50th home run of the season. Just casually making history, becoming the first player since Alex Rodriguez in 2001-02 to hit 50 homers in back-to-back seasons.

Oh, and get this—Ohtani is now the first player in MLB history to record 50 home runs and 50 strikeouts as a pitcher in the same season. The man is literally rewriting the record books while making it look easier than ordering takeout.

When Good Bullpens Go Bad

Here’s where the fairy tale turns into a horror movie. Manager Dave Roberts pulled Ohtani after 68 pitches—a decision that had the 44,063 fans at Dodger Stadium booing. Roberts later said, “He wasn’t going to go back out,” while Ohtani expressed his frustration: “As a player, I do want to pitch as long as possible.”

Enter Justin Wrobleski, who managed to record exactly one out before the wheels came off the wagon. The Phillies’ first hit came off him. Then the second. Then the third. Before anyone could grab another beer from the concession stand, Bryce Harper had cleared the bases with a double, Brandon Marsh had gone yard, and the Dodgers’ 4-0 lead had evaporated into a 5-4 deficit.

The Ninth Inning Nightmare

Just when you thought it couldn’t get worse, Blake Treinen entered the ninth inning chat. After allowing two baserunners, he served up a meatball to Rafael Marchan, who launched a three-run rocket that ricocheted off the right-field bullpen gate. The irony was thicker than LA traffic—the bullpen literally got hit by the ball that sealed their fate.

“Sometimes you look back and try to understand what’s going on,” Treinen said afterward, probably wondering if he’d accidentally wandered into a different sport. The final score: Phillies 9, Dodgers 6, and Ohtani’s masterpiece became nothing more than a beautiful footnote in an ugly loss.